I wrote a lot about the journey to the free lands of Navidrome, but what I haven’t dug into particularly so far is how I’m dealing with the rest of my media – particularly movies and televisions shows. I guess that’s partly because I’m so ethically *and* morally compromised there that it doesn’t make me look great, but also because it’s generally not very complex or interesting [1]. Architecturally, it’s simple – I have all my media files on a drive, Jellyfin on my homelab, and Jellyfin serves those media files as if I had my own private Netflix. Those files are a mix of stuff I ripped from DVDs I owned, and… well, other stuff. Let’s skip over that [2].
This is a largely seamless experience – Jellyfin works on tablets, on computers, and it even works on some televisions. Like everything else it’s hosted behind a shield of Tailscale, and even my mother can use it in Scotland despite it being it’hosted on my hardware in Sweden. Contrary to how Netflix and other streaming services work, you’re not geolocked if you control where the files sit.
I think though the part of this that’s most significant is an attitude rather than a technology, and it’s one that I’ve slipped into without really thinking about it over the past couple of years. It’s the whole ‘enoughness’ thing – so much of what’s produced today is in franchises I’ve had enough of. Not in the sense of being irritated, not ‘I’ve had enough of this shit’. More… ‘you know, that’s plenty. I have had sufficient, thank you.’.
I haven’t watched the Rings of Power, because I’ve had more than enough Tolkien. I haven’t watched… whatever any of those GRR Martin shows are, because by the end of Game of Thrones I’d had *more* than more than enough of Westeros thank you very much. I’ve watched a few of the Star Wars spin-off shows but… I think you get the point. Generative AI and extractive capitalism are moving us into an era where things never end, and that’s a problem. Things should end and we should be free to imagine the spaces they left unexplored in whatever way we want.
My wishes as a viewer – new, interesting media that introduces new characters and perspectives and contextualises them within a coherent theme and setting – are utterly at odds with the Capitalist drives that occupies large media companies at the moment.
In my new book I am writing about hauntology and nostalgia, and in it I talk about a ‘four quadrant’ model where the Sventlana Boym’s two conceptions of nostalgia (as restorative and reflective) serve as an attractor for the distributive force of hauntology which works in two gears (extractive and explorative).
The problem of modern capitalism in the frame of the creative arts is that is that it has switched from being explorative (finding new terrain to exploit) to extractive (exploiting the terrain it has found). They see Star Wars as a quarry to be mined – a rich vein to be blasted open to get at the rich vein of money inside. This, by the way, is also a sign of things coming to an end – you explore when you think there’s riches to be found, you exploit when you think there’s no more value in exploring. Franchise over-fishing is one of the predictors of the collapse of creativity in a capitalist frame [3].
You know what I haven’t seen enough of? Firefly. Carnivale. The shows that got killed before they truly found their feet. Do you know what I need? More of that. Do you know what I don’t need? Buffy. Again. [4].
So the technology – Jellyfin. Works fine. It’s free, can be self-hosted, and won’t pull the rug on you the same way Plex did. Plex – enshittified Jellyfin. Jellyfin – deshittified Plex.
The attitude – I treat franchise over-fishing the same way as I treat Perfect Fit Content on Spotify. It’s background, not foreground. It’s there to put on and ignore while I do something more interesting. But also, it’s not something I accept a recommendation for any more – really, I don’t care how good it is at this point. The creator should take whatever talent they showed and make something new with it. Recommendations from this point pm need more than ‘I think you’d like this’. It needs to be ‘This moves things on in a satisfying way, plus I think you’d like this’.
To be clear, I don’t mean that everything needs to be ‘one and done’. What I mean is when a Rights Holder (capital R, Capital H) looks at the back library of someone who made something unexpectedly popular and just strip-mines the shit out of it. If I get the impression that a show is being put together because it’s ‘monetizable’ as opposed to being an authentic work of passion, then you can miss me with it. If it’s a reboot, I want it to be meaningfully new, and done because the people involved have been fighting for it to happen [5]. I don’t want it to be ‘We have a Game of Thrones shaped hole in our schedule, what’s he done we could pad out to 45 minutes a week?’. The need to sell advertising or subscription fees is not, by itself, enough to earn my attention.
Like much of this year’s deshittification agenda, this is obviously a vibe based analysis. I’m sure even the most cookie-cutter exploitable franchises have people who care working on them. I’m sure there’s a real Skibidi Toilet fan who sees being on the team of the Michael Bay movie as the culmination of all their life’s work. But there’s a kind of aroma – a scent – of shit that sticks to the shovel that cleaned out the stable. If I smell that on something, I’m not going to give it the dignity of investment. Putting a big name on a franchise is more likely to get me to turn off than tune in.
Years ago I used to say ‘the worst thing about Star Wars is the Jedi. What they should do is use Star Wars as the background setting to start telling other kinds of stories’. And I think Andor is kind of the apotheosis of what I was hoping would happen – Star Wars is a resonant background noise to what’s actually a pretty gritty story of oppression. And I’m actually still kind of on board with this.
The problem is that the spiritual gravity of Star Wars is always the Force and the Skywalkers, and so in the end every story ends up being about the same thing. Andor (and Rogue One, the best Star Wars movie, fight me) are both outliers because they are essentially gritty stories about ethical compromise in a universe with simplistic ‘good versus evil’ cosmology. That’s interesting, it’s tension. But the Mandalorian – oh look, a baby Jedi. Acolyte – bad Jedi. Ashoka – a baby Jedi who was Skywalker’s apprentice. Kenobi – Skywalker’s mentor.
That’s what I mean by strip-mining a franchise – getting the excavators to ensure that no bit of fan appetite is left under exploited. It’s creativity with the sole purpose of leaving no money on the table. Andor and Rogue One are interesting mostly because the Jedi never really feature (at least in S1 of Andor, I haven’t watched the next one) – there’s only one terrifying scene with Darth Vader that really contextualises him as the galaxy-spanning boogeyman he’s supposed to be. That’s exploration of a franchise. It’s the *good* kind of hauntology. Of course, it’s not *only* explorative – the exploitation part is in there too – but I’m not demanding people make art for the sake of art. People gotta eat. Primarily though I want **world** service, not mere **fan** service.
The *fans* are what stopped The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi culminating in a meaningful critique of zealotry amidst a democratization of power. Instead it became ‘Oh look she has the right flavour of magic fizzy blood and that’s why she’s important’. Remember at the end of The Last Jedi when all those downtrodden kids found they were able to move things with their minds? The little sweeper slave kid who summons his broom to his hand? I swear I got chills at that. Rey had no special ancestor – she was just the first of a new generation of Force sensitives. That’s an incredibly meaningful story point. But no – the Fans needed Skywalker to be an unbreakable space wizard and so we killed off the promise of real, resonant story. The slave kid looks up into the stars with fierce determination having been chased away from his friends by his owner. He sees the trail of a ship entering hyperspace. The kid holds the broom like a lightsaber – and didn’t we all – and on his finger is the ring with the symbol of the resistance. Then the theme – **the** theme – swells. Seriously, goosebumps.
Look at what those two films are saying. ‘The Force doesn’t belong to aristocratic bloodlines. It’s available to all of us. And none of us are alone in the fight. You don’t need to be special to make a difference. Better days lie ahead, hope is never destroyed, merely temporarily mislaid.’.
And then the fan response.
‘Nah mate, nah. Bring Palpatine back, lol Rey should be his daughter somehow. And then can you make a little baby version of the green muppet and have a shiny Boba Fett look after him until Luke Skywalker comes in and saves the day?’
Look at that – it even sounds like something a twelve year old would type into a ChatGPT window.
That’s sadly most franchises when they focus on keeping the fans happy – they’re ‘What you’ve seen, but again with slightly different actors and in slightly different configurations’. Banksy was quoted once as saying ‘Art should disturb the comfortable and comfort the disturbed’, but most media these days is merely comforting the comfortable. Fine, if you want to get their money. Not so fine if you’re interested showcasing new experiences and new perspectives.
Nothing turns me off a book these days quicker than seeing ‘Tiktok made me buy it’ on the label. The blurbification of media -it’s House of Leaves meets the Blair Witch Project [6], it’s Disneyland meets Blade Runner [7] – has really codified what bothers me about modern culture. It’s focusing on telling you why stuff you don’t know about is like stuff you like. I don’t want to read a book that’s like all the books I’ve already read. I want to read a book that’s different from anything I’ve seen before. I accept that’s an unattainable goal, and becomes more unattainable with every book I read, but I want books that at least *strive* for distinctiveness. I’m not saying there isn’t a role for ‘comfort food’ reading or watching. I’m just saying it’s unhealthy for that to be the only diet you’re offered. Your cultural ingestion should include healthy nutrition as well as junk calories.
So yeah. I use Jellyfin for television shows and movies. It works well.
[1] Taking a big swing here in assuming nearly 6,000 words of Spotify and Navidrome commentary was interesting.
[2] If buying isn’t owning…
[3] As a comparator, I was recently introduced to the Amazing Digital Circus. It is in essence ‘I Have No Mouth and I Must Scream’ with an affable AI at its core rather than a murderous military supercomputer, and yet – it’s something new and invigorating, and could only happen these days outside the big studio model. And importantly, I don’t feel like anyone involved said ‘Hey, I Have No Mouth and I Must Scream is due for being monetized in a cutesy animated series’. The Amazing Digital Circus feels like the continuation of a dialog. Most franchises feel like the pub-bore that has already said the same thing five times but insists on repeating it again for the new people who just entered the bar.
[4] I loved Buffy, but it ran its course and ended elegantly. Leave it alone, you’re missing the whole point of the show. THE DEAD SHOULD STAY DEAD. Reboots are cultural vampirism.
[5] Like the proposed Firefly cartoon. I’m into it.
[6] The Backrooms [8]
[7] Westworld
[8] Note that the success of this has sent Hollywood into a frenzy looking for cult Youtube series to be monetized. I could imagine someone seeing the Backrooms videos and saying ‘This is awesome and needs to be taken to the next level’. That’s cool. The problem is people seeing the Backrooms **movie** and saying ‘What else is on the Internet that is currently under monetized?’.
